<div style="width: 100%; height: 200px; margin-bottom: 20px; border-radius: 6px; overflow: hidden;"><iframe style="width: 100%; height: 200px;" frameborder="no" scrolling="no" allow="clipboard-write" seamless src="https://player.captivate.fm/episode/a0bafdcd-466e-4ca9-9a78-51185d790fd7/"></iframe></div>
Do you need help with tracking online and offline conversions? Talk to us at: https://www.tiereleven.com/apply-now
The buyers worth the most to your business are often the ones your ad reports can’t see. They talk to a salesperson, close in a CRM, and never leave a trail back to the ad that started it.
In today’s episode, I share a case study from the hybrid brands we work with: an online store plus a sales team selling in bulk. I explain the difference between attribution and contribution, how one brand went from $5.6 million to $36.9 million, and why chasing the easiest close leaves your real customer ignored.
You’ll learn how to find your 80/20 of the 80/20, push offline conversions back into Meta, and lower your nCAC as the platform learns who to chase. I also cover where Google fits and where it doesn’t. It’s a loop, not a one-time fix.
In this episode:
- Offline conversions for hybrid ecommerce brands
- Attribution vs. contribution in multi-touch marketing
- Closing the gap between CRM sales and ad platform data
- Phone sales tracking for wholesale and bulk orders
- Using infinite look-back windows with first-click and last-click attribution
- Reducing Google Search over-reliance with Meta and top-of-funnel ads
- Feeding offline sales signal back to Meta to lower nCAC
- Finding your best customer avatar inside Shopify data
- Using sales team insights to build your messaging engine
- Seasonality, geography, and long sales cycles in attribution
Mentioned in the Episode:
Previous Episodes with John Moran: https://perpetualtraffic.com/?s=john+moran
Tier 11’s Data Suite: https://www.tiereleven.com/what-we-do/data-suite
Tier 11’s nCAC: https://www.tiereleven.com/ncac
Wicked Reports: https://www.wickedreports.com/
Tier 11’s Marketing Performance Indicators (MPI) Checklist: https://www.tiereleven.com/marketing-performance-indicators
Listen to this episode on your favorite podcast channel:
Follow and listen on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/perpetual-traffic/id1022441491
Follow and listen on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/59lhtIWHw1XXsRmT5HBAuK
Subscribe and watch on YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/@perpetual_traffic?sub_confirmation=1
Connect with Ralph Burns:
- LinkedIn – https://www.linkedin.com/in/ralphburns
- Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/ralphhburns/
- Hire Tier 11 – https://www.tiereleven.com/apply-now
Thanks so much for joining us this week. Want to subscribe to Perpetual Traffic?
Have some feedback you’d like to share? Connect with us on Apple Podcasts and leave us a review!
READ THE TRANSCRIPT:
The Revenue Your Marketing Team Can’t See
In terms of measuring it specifically when it comes to Amazon is actually a good way of doing this. You’re listening to Perpetual Traffic. I see tons of brands making this mistake.
They cut their meta ad spend because the in platform return on ad spend or ROAS looked absolutely horrible. But as soon as they do it, their Amazon sales and their Google sales completely disappear and they have no idea why. Well today we’re going to show you exactly how to see the full picture before you make that crucial mistake.
Hello and welcome to the Perpetual Traffic podcast. This is your host Ralph Burns, founder and CEO of Tier 11 alongside a four time now guest for Perpetual Traffic, Thomas McNaught. You’re one away from becoming like a certified like guest host here.
So congratulations on number four. Yeah. Yeah.
So maybe we’ll just hold off on number five just to kind of keep you like hungry about this whole thing. But no, welcome back to Perpetual Traffic and you’re gaining some notoriety in the internet space, which is internet marketing space, which is awesome because of the insights I think that you’ve brought to the last three shows and you’ve got a real zinger here today. So welcome back to PT.
(1:58 – 9:57)
Thanks for having me. Looking forward to it. You have a lot of challenges that you face as a growth strategist because as a growth strategist, you are responsible for basically everything performance related, which also includes, you know, we’ve had your colleague on here, Mer, who is you and her work very, very closely together at Tier 11.
And, but ultimately you’re the guy who’s the client looks at is like, he’s the guy who’s responsible for the whole shebang and not to minimize Mer’s responsibility or anybody on like the media buying or the creative team, but it all sort of falls on your shoulders. And I think one of the biggest challenges that I’ve certainly had in explaining this to people is what we talked about in the intro is how do you actually look at all of your channels together and aggregate all of those that would spend and or non-spend because those could be spend channels. Those could be Meta, Google, TikTok, LinkedIn, programmatic, but there’s also the organic channels, which is Google search, which is your AI search, which is your, you know, your email and SMS, all of those channels, they all work together to create a result for a business.
But the problem you see, and I see not in all businesses, but in lots of businesses is that they want to look at everything in its own individual silo. Like what is Meta doing? Like what is the ROAS in Meta? What is the ROAS in Google? What is Amazon doing if you sell on Amazon? And they look at every silo in its own, like as its own individual, you know, organism or its own individual environment and not the entire environment. And oftentimes as, as you and I know, so much of the advertising now, especially on those top of funnel channels, Meta, YouTube, programmatic, native, connected TV, there’s no click.
So you can’t really track. So we call this the halo effect, but it really is. It’s a challenge to be able to explain this to folks because that’s sort of how it works.
So that’s what we’re going to be talking about here on today’s show. And like, tell me about like your thoughts on that and how you see it, what your worldview is, and then last but not least, how you discuss this with clients who are spending hundreds of thousands, if not millions of dollars per month on paid advertising. Yeah.
A hundred percent, everything you said completely agree on. It’s like one of the toughest challenges that we face, especially anyone in marketing. And it becomes siloed for some of the reasons that potentially maybe you’re not managing every channel that the client actually runs paid on a lot of the time.
So they could be running display. They could be running Amazon. They could be running Amazon ads as well, or Google.
And we maybe only manage some part of that. We may just manage meta and the creative side. They might have another agency running their Google side or another agency on their Amazon.
And it’s hard because when an agency gets hired, I guess, or a team gets hired, the thing can become siloed to, well, I’ve hired them for this specific thing at this specific platform. And in a lot of the cases where we may or Google and a lot of the cases, but we also do display and other channels as well. And what happens is you focus mainly on that specific channel and the performance for that specific channel.
But as we know, there is this halo effect that does happen. And it happens across all of the different platforms. And the best way of looking at it, like we’ve talked about on other podcast episodes as well, as we really should be looking at your overall marketing performance and your MER, your marketing efficiency and seeing how everything is playing a part of that.
You can take it a step further and start looking at your new customer data, which is how our business is growing. Obviously, if you just look at your MER, you’re taking in returning customers and that, but really you want new customers for the business to continue to grow. And that’s what we really want to narrow down on.
So the mistake that people make is, well, for example, we’re spending, let’s say 100K on meta for the last month, and we’re only seen in platform, let’s say a 1.5 ROAS. But when you potentially look at that same info across your business, meta could be impacting the other channels, because it’s measured by last click on most of the channels that is also view through. So people could be seeing an ad on meta, but then they’re going to Google searching for you or chat GPT, like you talked about, which is even more common now in the modern day.
I was mentioning a thing that I do now is I screenshot ads and then I upload them into chat GPT. And I speak to them to ask about the brand or the product or the service. So people’s way of shopping, I guess, and way of using the internet is changing a lot, especially with AI coming into play.
The bigger one that we’re seeing is obviously Amazon. And Amazon becomes more difficult to track because it’s off of your main, if you’re running an e-commerce brand, for example, or any service based business where you’re running your own website, it’s hard to get that cross attribution between. Amazon doesn’t allow you to see it exactly.
So you wouldn’t be able to see, for example, someone who did come to your Shopify store and then jumped over to Amazon to buy, but we’ve got some stuff to talk about here in the podcast, which we can run over all of that. But yeah, that’s, that’s my general thought on how it works. And the bigger part, again, like we were talking about was things like meta specifically, and even like YouTube ads where there’s more like video plays being involved, these are definitely helping your brand, you know, and people underestimate them because they look at click data like we talked about.
But sometimes when you run ads, you could literally be racking up millions of viewers, millions of engagement on the platform, but people are just not clicking on those ads. And the way that we described it was, it’s kind of getting back to the way that it used to be what advertising, like people pay for billboards, you know, and you drive your car, but there’s no click data on the car. There’s no click data coming back to that ad, but still that billboard is getting engagement.
Essentially people’s eyes are going on it, people are seeing it, and it’s lifting your brand. You’ve got the same with TV ads. Now, some smart TVs now have got this fancy click data and everything built into it and QR codes and everything else.
But most of the time, it’s just a view that you’re seeing. Yeah, and it’s the same as YouTube ads, same thing. You’re seeing that lift through mainly the engagement on your video assets, which is definitely having a big impact.
And it could be impacting your other marketing channels as well, not just the one that we are potentially selling into, if it’s Meta or YouTube or any of the other engagement channels. So, yeah, that’s the main thing that we’re seeing. So when somebody says, or when a client says this, or conversations that you have maybe with colleagues and so forth, Meta does nothing for our Amazon ads, or Meta does nothing for our branded search ads, or YouTube doesn’t, like you need to measure all of these channels individually.
What’s your pushback on that? And what’s your answer to that? And what’s the solution to it? Because, you know, there’s, there’s a lot of different ways to look at it. And oftentimes, it’s a bit more art than science. And we’ve talked to Ricardo about this a couple of times as well.
But it continuously comes up, especially as more brands go multi channel, and multi channel, that we’re adding channels, like the AI channel wasn’t there two years ago, really. So there’s all of these different ways in which people will find you and ultimately buy. So when clients say those sorts of things, what’s your what’s your reply? Yeah, and it’s, it comes up quite a lot, to be honest, as something and I understand where the client is coming from, because maybe they feel that if the performance is not good on the account, and we are saying, well, this could be happening, where they’re thinking I never hired you for this, you know, but in reality, we’re doing this to make better decisions for you.
This is this is for your business. This is something that we think, or basically know actually helps your business by looking at everything overall. For the same reasons, like I mentioned, there’s going to be a bleed and your spend going across.
(9:57 – 10:36)
And a lot of the time, clients will think that we’re trying to take the credit from other channels, when in reality, we’re trying to make better decisions. That’s the biggest part of this, we could make very bad decisions for your business in terms of if we just looked at, let’s say one of the channels and silo again, let’s take me as the example. And we’re seeing as let’s say 1.5 was and that’s not what you’re really looking to go to.
And that’s your end platform number. But in reality, your MDR is left in your new customers are left and everything is going up. And if you really just look at that siloed any channel, it could be that you make the decision of to pull back spend and basically make the wrong choice of pulling back spend.
(10:36 – 11:45)
That’s what we’re really trying to help you know, it’s about making the correct decision and keeping the ad running that’s left in your whole business, rather than just focusing on one thing that’s because as we know, people shop around on sites, they go through different funnels, they check your Instagram, they go on YouTube, they check other brands, they go on chat GPT, and all plays a part and how much money you’re spending across all your channels to how much money you’re getting out of your Shopify store or your business, whatever it is that you’re doing. So is there any sort of rule of thumb when it comes to let’s talk about Amazon specifically, if you’re not selling on Amazon, like the equivalent of this is probably either the, you know, the AI search engines and or a Google search, which is typically maybe a branded search. So, but is there like, what do you look at? Is there any sort of rule of thumb based upon spend based upon engagement, any of that sort of stuff to be able to measure how that halo effect is affecting some of those very bottom of funnel channels like Amazon and Google and AI and, you know, to a certain degree, probably organic, like, especially if they show up, the business shows up pretty well on the organic side.
(11:46 – 12:11)
Yeah, on Amazon is a very common one. Because as we know, Amazon’s got the prime shipping, there’s incentives to buy on Amazon, you’re getting the next day delivery, you’re already paying for the delivery and a lot of brands that usually sell on Amazon and on Shopify, for example, this happens a lot. And it’s estimated between like anywhere, every dollar that you spend on your advertising, about 25 to 50 cents of that potentially Amazon will pick up.
(12:11 – 15:30)
So let’s say 25 to 50% of your traffic that you’re generating towards your site through meta ads, potentially is going and buying on Amazon. Now that will obviously vary depending on the site, the products, how much money you’re spending on these. So that’s kind of the rule of thumb that you’re seeing.
If you do a Google search, you’ll see a few studies on this as well, where they’re basically saying similar things. And that’s quite a big thing to be happening on your store if you’re not measuring it right. Imagine spending, for example, 100K and 25 grand of that is lifting up another channel and you don’t recognize it.
It’s basically you think that you’re wasting your money when you potentially you’re not, you’re just getting the money back from somewhere else. So yeah, that’s the estimate. In terms of measuring it, specifically when it comes to Amazon, is actually a good way of doing this.
So inside of Amazon, you can look at your search query, your search queries inside of your Amazon seller central. And basically what you can do is you can look at all the queries and you can filter them out by what would be brand search compared to just general searches on there. And you can look at the data across like one year, for example, even six months or three months, whatever you want.
The bigger the essay, I guess you’ll get the more accurate you’re going to see how this is actually impacting your results. Look at all your queries, let’s say for 52 weeks over the year, then you want to take any time that you’re running paid spend on other channels, look at your brand searches and check if they spike over the same periods where you’re spending more across the channels. Now what that tells you is when you’re spending on Meta or Google or TikTok or anywhere else, and you see a spike in your brand searches specifically, what does that tell you? Well, it tells you potentially people are coming and searching for your name because I’ve heard that from somewhere else.
And that’s the idea of how to check it. And you can look at the patterns across the 52 weeks or whatever amount of data that you get, and you can actually see how significant it is. You may actually find that you spend 100K and it lifts up by X percentage, or you drop it and it drops down by X percentage.
And we’ve actually seen this exact same thing happening across some of our accounts. And I know Ricardo’s got a great example of this. I don’t remember the specific account, but I’m sure they dropped, they were spending on Amazon ads and they dropped the spend to close to zero, but the Amazon revenue was going up as we were spending on the other channels.
And it’s like, that’s insane, right? You basically saved yourself thousands of ad spend on one channel and generating it from the same amount of ad spend on another channel just because that halo effect is potentially lifting it. So yeah, that’s how we would measure it. Look at the brand, put it simply, look at your brand queries on Amazon.
Super important. That’s a huge thing. I think it’s probably not something that most average businesses look at, but the effectiveness and the accuracy of that data being correlative, meaning I spend more on meta and I see more brand searches over on Amazon is also dependent on the cycle of first impression or first click to sale too.
So you’ve got perhaps, we’re talking about Amazon sellers here. So let’s talk about 100, $200 or less average order value is my guess. We’re not probably selling $10,000 pieces of equipment, but I assume we’re sort of using that.
(15:31 – 17:32)
So there’s always going to be a bit of a delay because we know that people don’t necessarily click and then buy, but they do view for a long period of time. We were actually at a client’s office just yesterday and they were telling me about people who have clicked 18 months ago and just bought this past week. So, and this is for a thousand dollars piece of equipment.
The point is this, is that it really does vary. So how do you make that correlation? Because I think that’s a really, really good insight. And it bears repeating here for people who are not exactly sure how to measure this halo effect.
Yeah, to measure it, there’s a few ways to do it. Obviously the software’s out there, which we won’t name any, but there is software that you can use. If you want to do it yourself, you can take all your ad spend together across your channels where your acquisition lives.
For example, Shopify and Amazon take the revenue that’s generated across all of those, break it down on daily, weekly, whatever you prefer. We do daily, weekly and monthly inside the tier 11. And then we do quarterly reports.
We also do six months sometimes and break down over the year at the end of the year as well for some of the clients. But on normal accounts, we look at daily, weekly and monthly. Usually you can track all of this and look at your key metrics as well.
So whatever that is, your targets you’re trying to hit and new customers. And yeah, that’s the important part as well. You want to look at your new customers coming into your business as well as your end end year.
Yeah. New customers is the main thing, right? Because new customers mean your best business is growing and you’re not just capturing people who have already known your brand. And that’s important as well.
So we look at NCAC and MER as well. And then your overall revenue and you’re also the volume and all of them plus the costs of all of them, all of them together. So we see if everything’s lifting as we spend or we see if things are dropping as we drop spend as well.
And we watch it all together, working together. Now, the mistake that you can make again, like we talked about is looking at things in silo, especially on different platforms. This is a key thing that a lot of people miss.
(17:32 – 19:17)
If you look at your attribution window inside of Google, for example, Google has a 30 day attribution on a click. Meta has a 70 maximum attribution on a clip. Now, if you think about that and you’re saying, let’s say again, it’s a 50 to $200 product that you sell.
Someone could come and click your ad and Meta and Google at the first day of the month. Now Meta will allow that to go to seven days in attribution, but someone could click on Google on the first of the month. Let’s say for an example, go to Meta, go to your YouTube, search your website, chat GPTU and at that space of the month of 30 days.
But then if they buy and they click on Google and still in that last day of that 30 day window, Google will say that sale was mine. And that’s a massive mistake to be making because you’re underestimating all your channels, which helped like we talked about even stuff that can’t be tracked, like your, your views, your video views, your engagement on things, people just seeing your ads and the ads being in front of people, same style as like a billboard or TV ads. Meta is definitely pushing your brand to people even though they might not be clicking on it.
And that’s important. So if I click on a Google ad on day one, I go then see an Instagram ad, which I will because I’ve clicked on a Google ad because Meta knows that I’ve clicked on that Google ad, which a lot of people don’t realize. And then I search, I do a chat GPT search, I go to the Instagram page, I then screen, you know, capture, throw it into of the product and then ask Gemini to tell me like, where’s the best place to buy it.
Then I go over to Amazon. And then I eventually buy it on an Instagram reel because some affiliate is giving me a 30% discount. Google will take credit for that sale as long as that’s within a 30 day window.
(19:17 – 19:27)
If your attribution is set up like that. And most of the time on Google accounts as most of the time, some people are good with it and they narrow it down. But that’s the default.
(19:27 – 20:32)
So I think it just bears iteration that people forget that in general. And that’s the reason why it is challenging to look at all this because you’ve got all these platforms that want to take credit. They really do.
Being platform metrics like Meta wants you to come back. Meta wants you. I mean, as soon as you go outside of the seven day window on Meta and the 30 day window on Google, you’re lost because you drop off.
I mean, that’s where the 2011 data suite will actually pick that up because it picks up that click into perpetuity. But you can also filter by first, last click. And then I think it’s measured is what they’re now calling it.
So there is sort of that middle ground there, but that’s very important to remember. So it makes the case for not looking at everything in silos even stronger just by understanding that. And just for people who aren’t familiar with it, and maybe it’s your Scottish accent, which is awesome because I’m from Boston.
So I’m like, we obviously love the Scots over here. Apparently we’ve got like, we’re sister countries now. I don’t know if you realize that.
(20:32 – 20:37)
After the World Cup. After the World Cup, yeah. In Scotland and in Boston.
(20:40 – 21:16)
I know that bar. I know that bar that they drained. There was actually a bar in Boston or the World Cup in the summertime, just an aside here, that the Scots came over, the Tartan army came over and drained.
They literally in one bar, there was no beer left. They drink all the beer. And this is Boston.
There is a bar on every corner. There is no lack of scarcity of beer. So anyway, so we’re basically sister countries now, even though Boston isn’t a country.
But anyway, we’ll set that aside for right now. Explain MER or media efficiency ratio. We’re not talking about Miranda, our creative strategist.
(21:17 – 23:23)
What is media efficiency ratio? Because that is something that you talk about here quite a bit, and we still use that. That’s the overall health of the business, but explain to people what that actually means. Yeah, I could put it in a very simple term, which is the way that I actually like to look at performance in general.
How much money you’re spending on your paid advertising to how much money you’re generating in your revenue. So it’s your efficiency ratio across everything that you’re spending. How much money is you getting out the other side of your business? And it’s just that simple.
And it’s that simple. Yeah. I don’t want to go try and make it fancy or anything else.
That is the best way of looking at it, in my opinion. And it is the most, because attribution can also trick people a lot of the time. Like we just talked about with the Google 30-day situation, that happens a lot.
And it’s like, well, 30 days is a long time for somebody to come back and buy, not think that any of the other channels played a part in that. And when it comes to just like, I am an Amazon seller and I’m selling on Amazon, like that data can be pumped into, can be piped into without the individual product, but the ad spend and the revenue from Amazon can be piped into the tier 11 data suite. And if you’re not the tier 11 data suite, you could do it through wake of reports as well.
So you get a level of accuracy to be able to look at all of your spend. We’re talking about the entirety of your spend, but if you’re selling a large portion of your particular products on Amazon, there’s a different economics over there because Amazon, depending on what your relationship is with Amazon, there’s different economics as opposed to just selling on your own Shopify store. So there is a way to look at this into its entirety and see the entire picture.
And that’s usually what businesses want. They want the entirety of the business to go lower left-hand corner, upper right-hand corner, steady growth. And they all work together to produce that result.
(23:24 – 23:59)
The economics on some channels are different than others. Amazon takes their fair share, but it depends on how much you’re selling. So how do you explain that to clients and to just in general? Yeah.
And that’s one of our challenges, I guess, is getting the message across for them to understand fully. And again, it’s something that I actually face quite a lot, but I think the best way is to try and show them it, and you set it up for them and get them seeing it. Once you get someone seeing it and you go, look, this is what’s happening, you can explain it clearly and show how it could be happening, where drop-offs could be happening as well.
(23:59 – 28:35)
Like something I notice a lot with the Amazon halo effect situation is you usually find this drop-off to add to cart and checkout on Shopify stores. And that happens a lot. And why does that happen a lot? Because potentially you’ve got Amazon reviews on your landing pages, which we’ve seen a lot of the time on Shopify stores, or you’ve also got shipping on your checkout.
And basically someone sees like, oh, it’s going to cost me $7 shipping. Let me just quickly check somewhere else. And they drop off.
They have that thought of, oh, I’ve got Amazon Prime. Maybe they sell on Amazon, and I’m going to get it tomorrow, but shipping takes five business days on the store. And then sometimes like we’ve talked about as well, as you go to Amazon and it’s cheaper for some reason, sometimes that’s just the way that it’s set up because you’re wanting to be competitive on Amazon as well.
Other people are selling similar products. What do you do? You start dropping your prices a little bit and then you end up with that situation. So I would say to answer the question, it’s trying to show them and explain it as best as possible through measurement of whatever I’m seeing, and that’s breaking down the funnel steps, putting the channels in on my own and getting access to them and showing them for a data suite or a spreadsheet that I can track the week on week and saying, look, hey, on Meta, we’ve raised the budget by 20% last week.
Meta stayed flat, but look what happened to your revenue on your Shopify store and your MER. Meta may be reporting something different, but everything else is lifting. Why is that? Well, brand search is picking things up.
Amazon is potentially taking 20% to 50% of the sales. We talked about 50% being a bit on the extreme end, but it could be happening. And when you look at everything together and you show them it and we measure it, then it starts to open their eyes and you can even show them the outcome of the revenue as well and say, look, this is what you’re left with after all your spend.
Even if you did spend this on Meta, you’re still walking away with more money. And we can show them that by showing them on a sheet or a data suite or however we want to look at it. The killer tip here is if you are selling on Amazon, what’s the downstream effect of what you’re doing on some of those more interruption channels versus the bottom of the funnel channel is really going into Seller Central, looking at your search queries or your brand analytics, and then figuring out what search terms are branded terms, and then measuring that with doing this as a test.
If you raise your Meta spend 10% on ads that are already doing well or 20%, and then you measure that downstream effect, whether it’s seven days, whether it’s 30 days, it’s going to depend on sort of what your first interaction to final sale really is for your product, somewhere between there and the products that we’re talking about here. That’s really the best way to measure the correlation. And then look at maybe your Amazon branded spend.
And Ricardo talks about this example quite a bit. And there’s a few others within tier 11, where you’re overspending on brand, which you don’t really need. Because if you’re just doing a search query, yeah, maybe the competition comes up ahead of you, but they’re not looking specifically for your competition.
They’re looking to check you out. Like, am I going to get that at a better price for that product versus what I would get on the Shopify store? Yeah, exactly. So just taking this to the next level, for somebody who’s not selling on Amazon, can you do the same thing through the Google Search Console, specifically for branded search on Google and measure that? Because we have plenty of non-e-commerce businesses that aren’t selling on Amazon.
What’s your strategy there to be able to sort of measure this halo effect on the top of funnel channels versus the ones that are on the bottom of the funnel? Yeah. So on Google, yeah, the similar sort of thing will be happening. The same thing, the more you spend, potentially the more is looking across.
And the same sort of thing, you can still search the queries inside of Amazon, but I would say that’s your best place to look is inside of Amazon. Now, the thing with Google that you’ve got as well that sometimes happens is Amazon actually spends on your brand name as well sometimes, which is another whole different thing going on as well. Amazon likes to take the top products and generate traffic towards that because they’re making money off of every product you sell as well.
So you can look and you can actually see that inside of Google as well. You can see your competitors who are bidding, your bidding competitors inside of Google and seeing where you sit against them. And sometimes we actually see Amazon has been one of the people on your brand search queries as well, which is crazy, right? And sometimes because of that, it might make more sense for you not to spend on your brand exactly what you talked about because that is already happening through Amazon.
(28:35 – 30:24)
You’re already selling on Amazon. So yeah, similar thing. Look on Amazon for the same thing, your queries that we talked about.
But then on Google, you can look at your competitors and see who’s bidding against you inside of Google and seeing how that is reflecting in terms of your whole business as well. So it’s this branded search trap to a certain degree. How would you describe that? Because bottom of funnel last click, and I mean, we’re getting a little bit in the weeds here, but bottom of funnel last click on a branded search term, let’s say it’s Thomas McNaught’s famous face cream.
You’re going to get branded searches for Thomas McNaught’s face cream or face or whatever it is over on Google if you are advertising to a great degree on meta. So how do you sort of explain that correlation between the two of those and how do you just enough Google trade or branded search ads to be able to get as high of a media efficiency ratio as possible if you understand that question? Yeah, I think I understand that question. Yeah, it’s quite in the weeds.
So you’re asking potentially how can we get the most efficient with brand search essentially? Is that the question? Yeah. So it’s a good question actually, because you’ve got so many external things happening, right? You’ve got even the fact that you potentially spend it on other channels is going to lift your brand search up. So you could be spending X amount a month on meta, let’s say 200K on YouTube and people are going to start obviously naturally go to Google or naturally go to your chat GPTs or even Amazon as well.
(30:24 – 31:10)
And getting efficient is, I guess it’s like you said, it’s kind of more of an art of trying to balance everything. So you look at how the channels when you’re spending more as lifting certain things up and look at how much you’re spending on, for example, your brand search, because again, the brand search, mostly the volume on that will be dictated by how much, I guess what we talked about, like demand generation versus demand to capture, you know, like how much of that are you trying to capture? And as time goes on, there’s going to be more to capture, especially if you’re lifting more of the spend up. And it’s the same with Amazon, it’s the same with Google.
You’re still want to be capturing those people, at least after they are. So to become efficient, I guess it’s just measure it week on week, day on day and see what you’re getting. Probably the best measure would be monthly.
(31:12 – 31:35)
Measure your overall, like we talked about your new customers. And then there is metrics inside of Google as well. If you really want to just look at Google and think, can I capture the brand demand? It will tell you that inside of Google.
It will tell you if you need to raise the budget, there is more search volume there for you to capture. And then you make adjustments, you measure it as you go. And then you, yeah, you see if it moves up or down your overall efficiency.
(31:36 – 31:42)
I hope that answers the question there. It is for your fictitious, you know, beauty brand. Face cream.
(31:42 – 32:13)
Starting to print out your face. I mean, maybe I should open that. We can put that in the bottom.
Put a link below. Leave a link in the show notes. If you’re going to see it, I love it.
I don’t know why I thought face cream specifically. No, the point of this is that there is like media efficiency ratio, I think is a really undervalued metric to, to be able to measure the entirety of the business. And this is not just, you know, an agency trying to get credit for stuff that they’re not creating.
(32:13 – 32:34)
That is not the whole goal. The goal is not to think of things in silos and to realize that the buyer’s journey is chaotic and messy. And it’s like you can’t predict what one person is going to do and extrapolate that to the millions of people that you’re trying to reach with your advertising.
(32:34 – 35:00)
Every person is going to have their own individual journey. And it’s not a direct line. It’s not one click.
Oh, a couple of more clicks. And then we buy what we’re seeing now when John and I talk about this on our Friday ad labs is people just seem to be, I don’t know how to say this, but he calls them the Wally fat people, which is basically people just want to sit there and just roll and not work, you know, and like clicking. Oh man, that’s so hard.
It’s just such a, like, then I have to go to a website and figure that out. I just want to get more information and not really do a whole lot of work. And that’s the world that we live in, which is almost going back to like what you, how we started out the show.
It’s like billboards and TV and radio. It’s like, just wash over people. And then finally they wake up.
All right, well, maybe I will use that, you know, or buy that vacuum cleaner that I’ve seen on TV 20 times so far. And I saw a billboard for it on my commute back and forth every single day. It’s almost like we’re back into that age now, especially with so much of our creative top of funnel being video to create awareness, consideration, and then last click conversion sometimes happens on the meta and YouTube channels, but usually it’s somewhere else.
Yeah. Yeah, exactly. And I think you on the podcast before you gave a good analogy.
It’s like, if you’re drunk, I think like what beat is it that got you drunk at the last eight, you know, like, and that’s the same applies to like a video view, you know, like you’ve seen the first, maybe you click the ad, you’ve viewed a video, you’ve seen something else, but what part of that actually converted someone? And it’s just touch points. It’s like the basics, right? The more touch points you get on someone. And that comes back to other things that we’ve talked about, like creative diversification.
Why do you want creative diversification? So you’re mixing up the touch points. You’re showing people more things, more angles, speaking to people at different awareness levels, which comes back to that whole thing that we talked about in another podcast. And yeah, just basically getting in front of it as much people as possible, but making the right decisions across your whole business.
And there’s another thing that John spoke about, I think he actually spoke about in the ad lab as well as like, well, if you think one ad is doing all the work and you think one channel is doing all the work, why not just put all the spend into that one channel? Why just run one ad and then see if that left out anything and catch 22 at obviously, that’s the point. Everything works together. So yeah, that’s part of it as well.
(35:00 – 36:34)
Well, I think there’s a lot of takeaways here for people who struggle with this. And of course, if you need our help in any of this and you need Thomas’s help, we can check us out over at true11.com of course. And I do think that this bears more discussion over time because it’s something that I don’t think is common wisdom right now.
It’s very rare that people see it this way because I think we’ve all gotten spoiled in the last 10 years in digital marketing because everything was tracked or we were just one channel marketers in a lot of ways, but in so many ways now it’s multi-channel and the vast majority of the clients that we work with, the vast majority of the people that I talk to on a weekly basis are doing this in a multi-channel way. And it’s become more and more complex, but we want everything to fit into the neat little silos when in fact that’s not how people really do behave and really do buy. So I think the insights here today are tremendous.
So I appreciate you coming back on the show for show number four, I think soon to be show number five to get you like as an official guest host or a part-time guest host here. Certificate. I get my certificate in number five.
I can put on my wall. I think you do actually. You get a perpetual traffic participation award.
So yeah. Yeah. And like Meta and Instagram, once you get to like a certain level, you get to put your affiliate link and the bio.
So you’ll be able to get my face cream below after the next podcast. Thomas’s famous face. I kind of caught the joke.
(36:37 – 37:57)
It’s all right. It’s all right. Well, the rest, there should be a risk warning.
If you use the face cream, you might develop a Scottish accent. So, you know, that is a side effect of Thomas’s famous face cream that we’ve promoted here. So anyway, super appreciate you coming back on the show.
And of course, for if you’ve been listening to the show for any period of time, we really do appreciate ratings and reviews, especially over on Spotify comments. Very much appreciated. Gets us out to a wider audience and try to teach people how to do this stuff the right way, because it’s complicated.
Somebody told me this past week who’s been in the digital industry and the advertising industry for 40 years, like this stuff is the hardest it’s ever been right now because there’s so many signals and so many things to be able to decipher. And I really appreciate you coming on Perpetual Traffic for the fourth time to help decipher those things. So you bet on behalf of Thomas McNaught, growth strategist extraordinaire here at Tier 11.
We appreciate you listening and watching. Check us out over on our YouTube channel at perpetualtraffic.com forward slash YouTube. And of course, everything that we mentioned here on the show is over the show notes over at perpetualtraffic.com. So until next show, everyone.
See ya. You’ve been listening to Perpetual Traffic.


